Nancy’s Problem With A Plagiarist

Hanging on our kitchen wall is a delightful calendar featuring fairies. It being the third month of the year there are three fairies pretending to be the three wise monkeys. It was produce by an extremely talented artist called Nancy Farmer who lives in the Ooo! Arr! Zider county of Somerset. However, Nancy is feeling far from Ooo! Arr! at the moment due to the Evil Plagiarist.

Last summer I wrote a post about artists learning their skills by copying the great masters and showed Constable’s version of a Jacob van Ruisdael landscape, and Ingres’s copy of Titian’s Venus. I’m sure that Ruisdael and Titian would have been happy, knowing that “imitation is the sincerest form of flattery”, because a) the copies were pretty good and b) neither Constable not Ingres posted the paintings for sale on YeInterWebe claiming “all ye owne worke”.

Nancy, as well as painting fairies, also produces works featuring Medusa. She discovered that an Evil Plagiarist (called Wendy Marani) is producing work based on Nancy’s paintings. I hesitate to say ‘copies’ because the paintings are so bad, but the ideas behind them are clearly those of Nancy. The EP’s versions are priced at $900. I am careful not to say that she is selling them at that price! Maybe if she paid someone that much to take them away ….

Painting by Nancy Farmer, plagiarism by Wendy Marani 3

Painting by Nancy Farmer, plagiarism by Wendy Marani 1

Here are Nancy’s two posts explaining her problem:

The Artist, the Plagiarist and the Medusa Paintings Part 1

The Artist, the Plagiarist and the Medusa Paintings Part 2

Obviously, Nancy’s problem with intellectual property theft is just a one off! Well, actually, it isn’t. There is a story going around Facebook (I’ve had it from two sources) about a Canadian wedding photographer called Barbara Ann who had one of her photographs used without permission and, when she challenged this, was accused of extortion. I can’t find a link so I’m copying Barbara Ann’s own words:

“There may be words that need to be eaten in this…or wish they had been. It seems that some of the corporate world believe the work of creative people is up for grabs simply because they show it online.

I am just a little fish. In a big pond. I am the one who stands up for the little guy in the corner when faced with the bully. Well, today I am standing up for rights and the rights of all photographers out there who get their work stolen. Today I am standing up for me.

It’s one thing to have another photographer steal your images and pass off as their own, but it is another to have a big radio station steal your intellectual property and try to blame you in the end. This has been my life the past 24 hours.

The new Hot 89.9 out of Ottawa Canada runs a contest every spring whereby couples get married in the span of 24 hours. I think it is a horrible, horrible contest and devalues marriage. It is certainly a contest I do NOT want my name or branding associated with. Imagine my shock when I see my image on their media/marketing kit info that entices potential advertisers to the contest to pay big bucks to be a part of it.

I contacted the radio station and they did not immediately get back to me. So then I contacted their owner, NewsCap Radio (who own a lot of radio stations across the country). They contacted me immediately expressing that they take copyright issue VERY SERIOUSLY. Well, everything was very serious until I mentioned that they were to compensate me for the illegal use of my image (AND ALTERED USE I MIGHT ADD). That is when the email tone turned negative.

The Vice President of NewsCap Radio offered me $40. When I turned him down, he emailed me the following:

“Barb you were kind enough to provide us with a few definitions. Here is one I just looked up:
extortion
NOUN The practice of obtaining something, esp. money through force or threats
SYNONYMS Blackmail-exaction

You are obviously a very talented photographer, I would stick with that. Extortion is not your thing.
Cheers
SB”

If they would have approached me to use the image, we would have had a chance to discuss the commercial use of it (IF I allowed the use of the image in the first place). However, once the image is used, I am at the disadvantage because the image is already out there.

I no longer want money from them. I instead want this story to be shared and shared and shared and shared. Maybe, just maybe, some marketing person at a company will read it and it will educate them to not STEAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY just because Google barfed it up on their screen.”

Advertisements

About notes to the milkman

I'm a printmaker based in the North West of England, living in Bolton and printing at Hot Bed Press in Salford. Please visit my website johnpindararts.weebly.com
This entry was posted in Art, Artists, Painting, Photography and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Nancy’s Problem With A Plagiarist

  1. aremraf says:

    Had an interesting weekend glued to the computer following Nancy’s marvellous posts and the ensuing comments. Great to see Notes to the milkman lending support, always an interesting and informative and energetic read. I mean, you have the energy, I do the reading.

    • I’m sure that if enough of us spread the word, the Evil Plagiarist will finally see the error of her ways!

      • Nancy Farmer says:

        Thank you again John! A great post…. I sniggered over “all ye owne worke”.
        It is possible that EP is so thick-skinned that the message is not in fact going to get through, but it is getting round to everybody else…
        At any rate the pictures are coming off ArtID.com one way or another as they are not standing for her behaviour either now they have seen the pictures! (ArtID, you may be interested to know, are run by lovely people, more fool her for picking a website with integrity to try to sell through!) Should not think that Facebook gives two hoots of course!

      • Nancy Farmer says:

        …I will of course post a progress update if there is any 😀

  2. kestrelart says:

    Still, entertaining pictures, Nancy’s. So unlike the life of our own dear Queen as my grandmother used to say of anything outside the suburban ordinary, or perhaps not …

  3. anneb54 says:

    Thank you for bringing yet a couple more examples to my attention. It is a real dilemma. What recourse does Nancy have? (PS sharing on Facebook)

    • All Nancy can do, and is doing, is to let as many people know about it as possible. I suspect that if anyone should Google ‘Wendy Marani’ shortly, there are going to more hits linking her to ‘evil plagarist’ than ‘wonderful artist’. But as Nancy says she is too thick skinned.

  4. Apropos: when we were teenagers we had a band whose name, translated into English, was “The Disgusting Disease Plagiarism”.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s