More About Photography In Galleries

(Being a continuation of the last post)

Some years ago, the Management and I were on holiday in Paris and went toddling off to the Louvre. The guide book stated that the best plan was to think of the Louvre as about seven museums, and visit just one of them while imagining that the other six were on the other side of Paris. As with many large museums, it is impossible to see everything so I found the guide book advise useful.

So we saw the Moaning Lizzie – from a distance of about twenty metres, as we couldn’t get any closer – then shuffled past the Venus de Milo, and a few other treasures. The Italian Renaissance section was heaving. There were notices everywhere stating that photography was prohibited. Any miscreants who ignored these were wrestled to the ground before being carried off in a tumbril to meet Madame Guillotine.

I soon tired of the crowds and suggested to the Management that we go and find some Dutch Golden Age paintings. Along a corridor and up some stairs and … where is everybody? Not a sinner in the place! I had Vermeer’s Lacemaker to myself (and given the choice between Mornin’, Lizzie and The Lacemaker, I know which one I’d have!) There were no signs in the Dutch galleries, so I asked. ‘Pas de problem, monsewer!’ (it being France) I was told. Clearly the restrictions in the Italian Renaissance galleries were not due to copyright or similar grounds but due to attempts to keep the crowds moving.

vermeer_lacemaker

One interesting aside is that I had no problem photographing The Lacemaker in its ‘home’ but was not allowed to photograph it during a temporary exhibition in Cambridge last year. Often photography is forbidden at temporary exhibitions with ‘lender’s restrictions’ being quoted. This is one of the questions discussed by Danny Birchall in his survey. Danny also has another blog post discussing this topic. Both posts are worth reading, particularly the survey one.

Here are some of the quotes from Danny’s posts:

“A suggestion, opposed to the general utopian current of capturing and sharing, that photography might be a mildly antisocial activity:

“A lot of visitors do not even ask if photography is permitted, but assume that they have a right to photograph any thing that they wish. Are there any suggested formula for a notice explaining the restrictions especially if other visitors are captured in the shots””

“Photography posted online or in print is neither a substitute for the museum experience, nor threat to attendance.”

“‘Personal’ photographs aren’t kept in lonely handfuls in albums any more waiting for their annual viewing to relatives; they’re published, labelled, tagged and discussed, part of an ongoing flow of conversation involving text and images. Perhaps you could say that ‘interpersonal photography’ has replaced ‘personal’ photography.” (This quote reflects Brett Roger’s comments in yesterday’s post.)

“The results of the survey seem to me to reinforce an almost cruel irony. The museum objects which you are allowed to photograph are often those least in need of personal capture and interpretation (they’re always there, many images of them already exist, they have been catalogued and interpreted) whereas the things that might benefit most from personal photography are those to which there is least access.”

One comment in reply to Danny’s post: “Irony: The Museum for Photography in Berlin strictly prohibits photography within the building. Particularly when the Abisag Tüllmann exhibition features an entire section featuring photos of people in museums and theatres.”

Advertisements

About notes to the milkman

I'm a printmaker based in the North West of England, living in Bolton and printing at Hot Bed Press in Salford. Please visit my website johnpindararts.weebly.com
This entry was posted in Art, Art Gallery, Photography and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to More About Photography In Galleries

  1. Red Hen says:

    Bon image. Monsewer! Having witnessed all those tourists taking pics all over Paris, I am very sure the Parisian curators don`t want similar crowds posing in front Mme Mona Lisa.

    • The above is NOT one of mine! What always amazes me in general, not just at art galleries, are the people who have to pose/have their photograph taken in front of things all the time as the default setting. On our recent holiday, I took several thousand shots (as per usual), The management and I were on about three of them, and our friends with whom we were travelling were on about five.

      • Red Hen says:

        Facebook has fed into the narcissistic tendency to be photographed with a famous backdrop, so you can imagine the queues at the art galleries in front of the best known pics if photography were allowed.

  2. This is a beautiful Painting John!! Thank You for liking my Drawing!! *Cynthia

  3. Pingback: A Walk On The Art Side | notes to the milkman

  4. Pingback: No Photography At The Whitworth | notes to the milkman

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s